A West Village bar run by the same family since 1961, with antique wooden booths and one of the city's benchmark burgers: a tall, greasy chuck patty served on a paper plate, with mugs of McSorley's ale. Proof that a great New York burger can still cost under $20.
- Address
- 331 W 4th St, New York, NY 10014
- Hours
- Mon-Thu 10:00-02:00; Fri-Sat 10:00-04:00; Sun 10:00-02:00
- Best time to go
- Evening, Late night · About 1 h
- Price
- Cheeseburger $14.75, fries $6.50 (The Infatuation, 2026)
- Price level
- $
Details can change. Check hours and prices before you go.
Good to know
- Bring cash (The Infatuation).
- Order your own thin, salty fries; nobody shares.
- Open until 2am (4am Friday and Saturday); a second branch opened at 94 Avenue A in the East Village in September 2025.