A cash-only seafood counter at the very tip of City Island, with a concrete patio on Long Island Sound. Order fried shrimp, scallops or clams in a red plastic basket, steamed lobster tails and a frozen Henny Colada.
- Address
- 2 City Island Ave, Bronx, NY 10464
- Hours
- Mon-Thu 11:30-22:00; Fri-Sat 11:30-23:30; Sun 11:30-22:00 (Google hours via Wanderlog, 2026-10)
- Best time to go
- Afternoon, Evening · About 1.5 h
- Price
- Beers about $3, lobster tails about $40 (Time Out New York, 2026)
- Price level
- $
Details can change. Check hours and prices before you go.
Good to know
- Cash only; order at the counters inside, then grab a picnic table.
- Any day above about 59 degrees F is 'Johnny's Reef weather', as The Infatuation puts it.